Wednesday, December 7, 2011

Reinventing Discovery: Book Review, Part I


In Arthur C. Clarke's story "Into the Comet" he describes a spaceship with a computer malfunction that dooms all abroad to eventual death by starvation/oxygen deprivation, whichever comes first. The solution is a device older than the computer: the abacus. The entire crew ran calculations on acabi, and they make their way out of the comet's nucleus successfully. That is an extreme example of citizen science (or oh-my-God-we're-all-going-to-die science) but it shows the principle, that collaboration by a large number of people can solve very complicated problems. Michael Nielsen's excellent book, 'Reinventing Discovery' tells us about many such examples, though in most of them participants have to do a lot more than just calculate without thinking.






Take 'Galaxy Zoo': volunteers can help classify galaxies (it turns out people do it faster and more accurately than a computer). It all began when one overworked grad student, Kevin Schawinski, wanted to prove that elliptical galaxies aren't always old, but had simply too many galaxies to go through in order to prove his theory. He and a post-doc, Chris Lintott, joined forces and opened a website which allowed anyone to come and classify galaxy photos. The project is an enormous success, with 22 scientific papers so far and the spin-offs Galaxy Zoo 2 and Galaxy Zoo:Hubble.

Another story Nielsen recounts is the story of the Polymath Project: Fields Medal recipient Tim Gowers posted a mathematical problem in his blog and asked for a collaborative efforts. Twenty-seven people wrote 800 comments and solved the problem within 37 days. Now there is a Polymath blog which keeps up the good work.

These projects were a success, but Nielsen also studies failed projects and the reasons for their failure. He argues (which I wholly agree!) that scientists are rewarded by writing as many good scientific papers as possible. Contributing to, say, Wikipedia, essentially takes away time from research and gives nothing in terms of academic reputation.

Galaxy Zoo is a success because it gives astronomers something to write about, and it's possible the Polymath project succeeds because it A. involves people with tenure and B. involves people who want to be noticed by people with tenure.

Personally, I think the solution to scientists' reluctance to cooperate in collaborative projects is simple: put them in a spaceship and tell them they won't be able to make it home until they collaborate. However, it is possible the oxygen run out while they'd argue about whose name gets to be first in the authors' list. Also, spaceships are very costly.

Next part: what Nielsen has to say about Arxiv and the future of open science.






Michael Nielsen talks Open Science in a TED event:


Nielsen, Michael (2011). Reinventing Discovery Princeton University Press Other: 9780691148908

14 comments:

  1. Invention is the stepping stone. In the first part you have written well about everything. Hoping the next part will soon happen.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks for sharing this nice informatio GoMovies

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thanks on your marvelous posting! I really enjoyed reading it, you’re a great author.Please visit here:
    Packers And Movers Chennai

    ReplyDelete
  4. Thank You For Updating Me With this book review.
    Insulated Plasterboard Visit Now For More Information

    ReplyDelete
  5. EvSye Facility Management sets the benchmark for Facility Management Services in the UAE. Our commitment goes beyond maintaining spaces; we craft a unique customer experience, ensuring consistent delight. With an unwavering focus on excellence, we also prioritize an exceptional employee experience. Our dedicated team ensures every facility is meticulously managed, resulting in happy customers and motivated staff.
    Facility Management Services Dubai, UAE -y choosing EvSye Facility Management, you're not just partnering with a service provider; you're gaining a dedicated ally in creating extraordinary spaces and fostering unparalleled customer and employee satisfaction.

    ReplyDelete